When Umpires Fail, Fans Should Take Over
It is no secret that the umpires have been absolutely atrocious during the baseball playoffs this year. And don’t tell me that it’s the volume of HDTV sets and advancements in video technology that have brought the imperfections to light.
Being an umpire is not difficult work. It requires concentration, a certain level of equanimity, and a willingness to spend much of your life traveling. Beyond that, there are very few responsibilities.
Out or safe?
Foul or fair?
Ball or strike?
There is much less gray area than people realize.
You have probably heard by now, but during the Yankees/Angels game the other day, the homeplate umpire actually asked the catcher to crouch lower so he could get a better view of the strike zone. What a joke!
Then it occurred to me: sporting events are for FANS – so what not have the very people who support the industry help make decisions?
You’re probably thinking that fans are too biased and will only side with their team. I’m not convinced that is true, but I’m sure we could insert a control to neutralize the playing field.
Here’s what I propose for the baseball playoffs next year…
Whichever network is carrying the game should have a group created on Facebook and Twitter comprised of former baseball players and umpires. When there is a controversial call that requires a review, this pro group acts as the deciding vote. Heck, even if it’s not an official ruling, wouldn’t it be neat to get a mass perspective from people who actually played the game?
This is where social media and sports should converge, and I’m confident it will. I’d be more than happy to run the operation. I have more faith in the fans than the boys in blue.
